On the day of January 20, the first President of the United States, Donald Trump, thought about the Gaza Strip as a “great location”, where “beautiful things can be done.” Then it came as a proposal on January 26, when the correspondents in the Air Force told one that the Palestinians should be transferred to Egypt and Jordan to “clean” the pocket.

The question of whether this is a serious proposal, and whether any displacement of the Palestinians would be temporary or always not clear, as Trump continued to make accidental comments on this topic.

But after that, on Tuesday, he appeared with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the White House – on the first official visit by a foreign leader since the opening of the new president – Trump is a bomb, announcing that the United States will work “The seizure” and “private” GazaHoping that “the Palestinians there will go to other countries” while it can reach ethnic cleansing.

On Wednesday, press secretary, Caroline Levitte, said that Trump did not abide by the time of the American forces on the ground in Gaza, and that the people who live there “will be temporarily transferred”, while providing few other details about a plan that was widely rejected by the Palestinians and the Arab countries – Including Egypt, Jordan and Saudi Arabia – and many countries at the international level.

Here is everything you need to know about Trump’s suggestion and if it is serious or if his plan is possible.

Why did Trump issued a Gaza Declaration? What does he really want?

Trump’s real intentions are often difficult. The man who published a book entitled The Art of the Deal himself is proud of the acumen of negotiation, and it may be difficult to distinguish between what is his position to start and what is the ultimate goal – or even if the ultimate goal is currently present.

“The attempt to preserve the psyche Donald Trump is an exercise in uselessness,” Yasmine Gamal, a policy analyst in the Middle East. “Nobody knows what is in Trump’s head.”

And she continued, “It is difficult to imagine it believes [the US] You can enter, pushing people, and as Trump said, “The People of the World” to live there. It is completely imaginary … It is important in the meantime to continue not to normalize these types of ideas, but to assess the actual reality on the basis of Arab positions. “

This declaration could be an attempt to make the right of Israel the maximum – who called for the illegal Israeli settlement in Gaza – Said after his anger at his support for the ceasefire on the Israeli war in the pocket.

It can also be interpreted as an attempt by strong Arab countries to finance the rebuilding of Gaza – Trump’s National Security Adviser Waltz frame the plan as one of the many. “[Trump’s announcement] “It will bring the entire area to reach their own solutions,” Waltz said.

How feasible is the idea of ​​taking over the United States Gaza?

Trump’s comments were shocked even his most enthusiastic supporter-cited beauty of the Republican Union of Senator South Carolina Lindsey Graham as one example. Graham questioned support, even from the Trump base, making America great again, for the American forces on the ground in Gaza, a point by many other Republicans.

Then there is the fact that two million Palestinians will be expelled from their land – with the vast majority There is no desire to goWe also saw the immediate return to northern Gaza by hundreds of thousands of Palestinians who were displaced to the southern region during the war.

There is no doubt that there is an armed resistance of any efforts to clean the Palestinians from Gaza ethnically, and although Israel is roaming in Gaza for 15 months of fighting – killing more than 61,000 Palestinians – its army was unable to crush the Ballistan resistance forces.

In fact, although the losses are attached to Hamas, the group has It is said Many fighters recruited as they lost and fixed a lot of their infrastructure.

Tariq Kenny-Pahawa, an American political colleague in Palestinian research in Shabaka, said that there are many reasons for expelling the Palestinians from Gaza on the way Trump says, and he will make the president’s chances of achieving goals, and he will make the president’s opportunities to achieve goals, such as normalization between the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Saudi Arabia and Israel.

“The United States” takes over “Gaza will not hinder the chances of American interests in the region that has been achieved, but it will also fly against the first principles of America’s heart.”

Republican Senator Rand Paul, from Kentucky, a common American isolation between Trump’s base, explained this point as social media on Wednesday, saying: “I thought we voted for America first. We have no work that is thinking about another profession to ventilate our treasure and poor blood soldiers.” .

Sami Hamdi, journalist, adviser and political advisor, said it was difficult to imagine Trump supporters to support the presence of American forces in Gaza. He told the island’s rules: “Instead, it may be that Trump is pushing for a compromise, as the warm regional powers of Israel are a” regional peacekeeping “force to contain Gaza.”

What is the position of the Arabs ’allies?

Beauty indicated that the American partners are in the region Renounce Trump’s proposal directly.

“The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia was very determined to broadcast the same message Make a statement At 4:30 am their time. Al -Jamal said: “They did not wait until working hours to say that she is not a student.” “This cannot happen without the approval and participation of Arab countries, so the question becomes what is the alternative to this plan?”

King Abdullah from Jordan is scheduled to visit the White House next week. Journalist Levit, the secretary, indicated that the monarch may change his opinion and accept Palestinian refugees from Gaza, just as the other world leaders have retreated in confrontations with Trump since the presidency was reshaped.

Is foreign acquisition on Gaza a new idea?

Israeli politicians have always been a fantasy to take Gaza.

Israel had previously built illegal settlements in Gaza before it was directed by former Prime Minister Ariel Sharon in 2005. Israel has since expanded illegal settlements in the occupied West Bank and occupied East Jerusalem.

Sharon justified the disengagement in Gaza on the pretext that the Jewish Israelis would not form a majority in Gaza. However, Israel continued to control Gaza and the air field over it, imposing a siege in 2007, which led to the comparison of the pocket with a “outdoor prison.”

At the beginning of the war on Gaza, a document leaked from the Israeli Ministry of IQ proposed the movement of Palestinians from the region to the Sinai desert.

Netanyahu reduced the idea in public places – ethnic cleansing is against international law – but his supporters, including ministers in the government, continued to pay the idea. After Trump announced, the Israelis welcomed all over the political spectrum of the idea.

“This idea is very meaningless, but what the Israelis were pushing for some time,” said Diana Bhutto, a former adviser to the Palestine Liberation Organization and her expert in Israel and the females.

“It is not unique for Trump,” she said to Al -Jazeera.

How does Trump benefit?

In March 2024, Trump’s son -in -law suggested that Israel should remove the Palestinian population from Gaza and clean the tape, saying that “the property of the waterfront in Gaza may be of great value.”

He added that the population can be transferred to Egypt or to the Niqab desert (NEGEV) in southern Israel – supporting the first Israel and refuses to look at the latter.

Analysts say that Kushner is a real estate pole man who was assigned during the first period of Trump to manage the Israeli -Palestinian peace process, which had already ended for two decades.

During his last speech, Trump chanted some Kushner’s feelings.

“[We’ll] Make it in an incredible international place. I think the capabilities of the Gaza Strip are incredible. “

“I think the whole world, representatives from all over the world, will be there and will live there,” he added.

Buttu believes that Trump ignores the welfare of the Palestinians, their history or culture.

“Who are you to decide that we want the Riviera in the Middle East that determines our history completely?” She said.

“[The majority] Gaza residents are not even from the Gaza Strip and they only want to return to their homes [in what is today Israel]. Why is this not a more practical choice? “

Is Trump’s plan part of Netanyahu’s goal to eliminate Hamas?

It is true that “eliminating” Hamas is often martyred as a goal and a reason for the destruction that is being confronted in Gaza, but observers say that Israel’s true motives are different.

It is an excuse by the Israelis to confirm. They have always insisted out loud on this type of “divine claim” in Gaza. This dates back to before October 2023, “Political Counselor Hamdi said.

“In this regard, the Israelis welcome the Trump Declaration [about expelling all the people in Gaza]. However, Trump also imposed a ceasefire, which many Israelis have ever wanted. My instinct is that Trump does not tend to support the continuation of the war and wants to find a way to empty Gaza without one. “

Hamdi also questioned that Hamas could be completely eliminated.

“Many people still support Hamas. We saw this after the ceasefire. He said that the idea of” resistance “is older than Hamas, and Hamas is simply a manifestation of its modern manifestations because the Palestinians are trying to stop pushing Israel unabated to remove them from their homes.

This is what many people in Washington now ask. If they go there [as Trump has said] Resistance may shoot them. Is the United States – the American public – is ready for another Vietnam? “