Egypt and Jordan have refused to propose US President Donald Trump that Gaza should be “cleaned” and the remainder of its population before the war of 2.3 million moved to the neighboring countries.

Trump, who led to the idea of ​​the idea on Sunday, repeated on Monday while he was on the first air force as he answered a question about whether the remaining residents of Gaza will supervise the short or long -term term. Trump reiterated that he “wants to get [Palestinians from Gaza] They live in an area where they can live without disrupting, revolution and violence a lot. “

The Israeli media reported that the US special envoy Steve Witkeov discussed the idea with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in Jerusalem on Wednesday.

According to reports on the Israeli public radio, Witkoff pressed Netanyahu to remove any political obstacles that remained the three stages of the ceasefire deal between Israel and Hamas earlier this month. They also discussed the proposal that the residents of Gaza are displaced to Egypt and Jordan.

While no official details of the meeting were launched, senior officials later told Channel 13 that they “have the impression that the Americans are serious about this idea, and that it is not just a conversation.”

This is not the first time that Trump has made statements about his desire to get rid of the geography of the world.

In addition to his comments on Gaza, he suggested that land Greenland It is included by the United States, Panama channel Recovered under the control of the United States and the Gulf of Mexico is renamed The Gulf of America.

However, 15 months after the uncompromising aerial bombardment and the invasion of the land by Israel, killing about 47,354 people, wounding 111,563 and destroying about 60 percent of the housing in the pocket, which is in Gaza where the last Trump idea was symbolizing Until the greatest human effect.

What is the response to Trump’s idea in Gaza?

Almost everyone outside Israel, including Egypt, Jordan, the United Nations and Palestinian leaders, rejected the idea.

Egypt

On Wednesday from the west, the head of the shield Tell a press conference“With regard to what is said about the displacement of the Palestinians, it can never be tolerated or allowed because of its impact on Egyptian national security.”

He told reporters: “The deportation or displacement of the Palestinian people is an injustice that we cannot participate in.”

The American President’s claims were also rejected that he discussed the matter with Egyptian President Abdel Fahia Al -Sisi as wrong by the Egyptian information service.

Jordan

Jordan also condemned this plan, as King Abdullah II stressed during meetings in Brussels with European Commission President Ursula von der Lynn, European Parliament Speaker Roberta Mitsola and European Council Speaker Antonio Costa, and the importance of the Palestinians to be able to stay on their land.

Palestinian leadership

Palestinian leaders also rejected the idea.

Mahmoud Abbas, the nominal leader of the Palestinian Authority, condemned “any projects” aimed at removing the people of Gaza outside the pocket, while the Hamas leaders, who supervise Gaza, told AFP that the Palestinians “will go into such projects”, such as projects, “such as they have done. Similar plans for “displacement and alternative vulgarity over the decades.”

United Nations

The United Nations, which maintains support for the two -state solution stipulated in the Oslo agreements in the 1990s, also responded to the idea of ​​transferring Palestinians to neighboring countries.

During a press conference on Monday, UN spokesman Stephen Dujari also rejected the Trump planTell the reporters, “We will be against any plan that will lead to the forced displacement of people, or may lead to any kind of ethnic cleansing.”

Other countries

In addition to those involved directly, a number of other countries were also criticizing the Trump plan to transfer Gaza population, including Germany, whose leader, Olaf Schultz, rejected the proposal to be “unacceptable.”

French Foreign Minister Jean -Nou Baroot also refused the idea, and told the France Parliament on Tuesday that the proposal of the US President was “absolutely unacceptable.”

Spain, one of the two countries within the European Union to recognize the state of Palestine, condemned this idea, as Foreign Minister Jose Manuel Albaris told Euronos that “Gaza belongs to the Palestinians and the people who live in Gaza.”

The Arab Association also opposed the plan strongly, as it issued a statement on Monday, saying: “Forced displacement cannot be named and people are evacuated from their lands except” ethnic cleansing. “

Who supports Trump’s idea of ​​moving the Palestinians to neighboring countries?

Many right -wing Israelis.

The idea of ​​removing the Palestinians from Gaza and replacing them with the Israelis was common among a large part of the Israelis since the illegal primary Israeli settlements It was removed from Gaza in 2005.

It took new importance in the eyes of many after Hamas’s attack from Gaza in southern Israel October 7, 2023, which killed 1139 people.

A conference, held in Jerusalem in January 2024 and its address entitled A settlement brings security, Drew 12 Ministers of Cabinet, including the Zionist Extremist Finance Minister, Bezallil Sottic, and the former Minister of National Security, Itamar Bin Ghaffir. Both participated in the discussions focused on “voluntary” immigration of the Palestinians from Gaza and their subsequent resettlement by the Israelis.

Along with other right-wing ministers, Ben-GVIR and Smotrich welcomed Trump’s proposal to transfer the Palestinians to neighboring countries this week. Smotrich reported on Monday that he was already setting a “operational plan” to convert Trump’s idea into an implemented Israeli policy.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu did not publicly comment on Trump’s proposal. However, many observers explained to him A recent invitation to the White HouseThe first international leader to ask him, as evidence of the level of support that Trump intends to extend to Israel, despite many War crimes are concerned and Genocide allegations Against the state because of its war on Gaza.

Is Trump’s suggestion legal?

no.

“The proposal to transfer the Palestinians from Gaza to neighboring countries from forced displacement, which would violate international humanitarian law,” Michael Baker, professor of international human rights law at the Trainte College in Dublin, who was previously working in the International Court of Justice, said Al -Jazeera.

Baker added that if Trump’s proposal, if behavioral, can remove the land to include Israel’s subsequent Israel, a verb that Baker said was “a violation of the basis for the ground for the land by force.”

Baker added: “International courts have also found that whether population transport is forced displacement depends on whether people have a real choice in this matter,” Baker added. “This means that even if some Palestinians may agree to the transition, this will not necessarily make the displacement legally.”

Is this enough to stop any plan to transfer the Palestinians from age?

Maybe not.

The United States remains the most powerful country in the world, where many within the international community depend on trade, and in some cases, Defense.

Even the United Nations, which criticized Trump’s comments, receives 22 percent of its annual budget – does not include the cost of peacekeeping – from Washington.

Even if the United States is not one of the most powerful states in the world, there is no mechanism to prevent it from violating international law, as Laila Elieva of Oxford School for International Studies and the region said, noting the failure of the United Nations and the East the International Criminal Court (ICC) to curb Russian work in Ukraine.

“I would like to say that unprecedented public opinion this time can be a factor,” Alleva said, although the addition of the warning, within Europe only three states – Ireland, Spain and Norway – recognizes Palestine, and that Trump may not care about others.